Although this beauty is not new, it’s only my first of the Highclere Castle line from Foundation Cigars. I remember a few months back when I first took note of the price point and did a double take, as it stood out from the rest of the brand. But just a little research added some much-needed perspective.
Turns out the folks over at THE Highclere Castle – made famous by the hit television show Downton Abbey – wanted to create “a cigar reminiscent of those enjoyed at Highclere Castle during the 19th and early 20th centuries,” and chose to do so through a partnership with fan favorite Nicholas Melillo.
Sounds good! But is it good enough to warrant the price point? Keep reading to find out…
Highclere Castle Edwardian Toro (6×52)
WRAPPER: Connecticut Shade
BINDER: Brazilian Mata Fina
FILLER: Nicaraguan
BODY: Medium
STRENGTH: Mild-medium
FLAVOR: Mild
THE JOURNEY: Not gonna lie: going in, my hopes weren’t the highest. I am a huge fan of Foundation’s bolder lines and was basically expecting something similar to the Charter Oak, which is solid – especially at the price point – but not really my jam. What I got instead was an inarguably masterful, satisfyingly smooth blend that is clean and pleasing on the palate. The elegance and finesse is undeniable from the silky-smooth aesthetic of the tan wrapper, to the picture-perfect burn and thick ash. There is a subtle creaminess that keeps the smoke from feeling empty or tasting bland or dry when balanced with the secondary note of breadiness. Unfortunately (for me), however, there was not much else I could gather by way of complexity or intrigue.
I’d compare this blend to what I imagine draws one to a top shelf vodka. What makes it so good is that it’s barely there, still satisfying, and doesn’t leave you feeling gross the next morning. So if you’re a fan of a more unobtrusive yet fulfilling blend, I highly recommend this offering. If you’re looking for the complexity and boldness of some of Mr. Melillo’s other ligas, however, opt for a meatier Connecticut instead.
